A loosely moderated place to ask open-ended questions
Search asklemmy 🔍
If your post meets the following criteria, it’s welcome here!
- Open-ended question
- Not offensive: at this point, we do not have the bandwidth to moderate overtly political discussions. Assume best intent and be excellent to each other.
- Not regarding using or support for Lemmy: context, see the list of support communities and tools for finding communities below
- Not ad nauseam inducing: please make sure it is a question that would be new to most members
- An actual topic of discussion
Looking for support?
Looking for a community?
- Lemmyverse: community search
- sub.rehab: maps old subreddits to fediverse options, marks official as such
- !lemmy411@lemmy.ca: a community for finding communities
Icon by @Double_A@discuss.tchncs.de
- 0 users online
- 228 users / day
- 943 users / week
- 2.44K users / month
- 5.59K users / 6 months
- 1 subscriber
- 3.07K Posts
- 119K Comments
- Modlog
It’s like having different email providers.
They will all send and receive email, although some might try to cut down on spam by blocking email from other specific providers.
Also, certain providers will host different email newsgroups (ie communities, ie “subreddits”)
For the most part, it doesn’t matter. Although there are some instances that choose not to communicate with each other.
Instances that promote disinformation and hate speech often get blocked. More over, instances that have vulnerable people are selective about who they federate with.
Similar to Mastodon, the different instances can represent single individuals, a small group of friends, a shared common interest, or host anything. It allows a “local” feed but can also connect to any part of the federated network. An instance might even choose to not broadcast to the larger federation at all.
These instances also spread out the workload of any single server by decentralizing the network, which allows Lemmy to grow without falling into a capitalist growth method.
That’s fuckin’ awesome! Kind of like a digital syndicate!
The difference is different admins, different policy (for example one lemmy could let anyone in, another, like beehaw asks to write why they should let you in, and that you will obey their rules).
There are also things like some settings, for example beehaw disables downvotes, they also don’t federate with lemmy servers that notoriously break their policies.
So best bet would be to choose server which policy fits you the best.
Also some people might want to choose the biggest and most open server. That could be good but because the server is open to everyone it might struggle fighting abuse and also go down because of high load. Such server is lemmy.world right now.
BTW: this might be useful https://github.com/maltfield/awesome-lemmy-instances
You know how on Reddit people were always bitching about the mods or admins? With federation, you can choose your mods and admins. Still won’t stop you from getting banned from certain communities, but if mods take it too far, you can just start a community on a different server.
Like a democracy or what? Lol. How do you choose them?
The instance can control it and another instance can create a “competition” of the same instance. Diffrent mods for each and not being locked to 1 type.
Though hopefully we get something similar to supper communities that are multiple of the same under 1 listing
I mean, there’s no vote or anything. It’s just that if you don’t like the moderation policies of one instance, you can just create an account on another one that aligns more with what you prefer.
I kind of like the idea of someone “campaigning” to be a mod. It could be a highly entertaining shitshow.
Can you imagine a debate between candidates? Lmao
On Hexbear you get to look at dope ass bears all day.
That’s a dope ass bear right there
This is an excellent case in point — for most instances there kind of just, somebody felt like making an instance and here it is. If you don’t know anybody specifically there’s not much reason to pick one over another. Maybe in future somebody will start up commercial instances like email providers and charge extra to have better reliability or a cool name or whatever but so far the instances seem to be pretty much run for the sake of neighborly kindness and fun.
Some instances have enough of a special interest that they get a distinct identity and reputation.
If you go look at what’s posted/hosted locally on the hexbear instance you’ll see it’s got a shit-ton of general trolling, shit-disturbing, lib-pwning, and general 4chan activity. If that’s your jam, you can sign up there and have a “local” feed with that kind of content, concentrated.
Meanwhile I’ve seen a number of calls to defederate from hexbear recently and if you sign up there you will not see or interact with whomever is posting from those instances who say no to trolling.
4chan activity? I mostly post ska.
Every day, too!
Is there an opportunity for ad monetization as a commercial instance? Because so far I haven’t seen any
I think (don’t quote me on this, because I’m not sure) that the license agreement for kbin/Lemmy instances specifically forbids advertising. Then again, maybe I’m remembering an incorrect remark that some doofus made. I don’t know.
I was talking about charging subscription fees for the instance login, not ads. I imagine if you wanted to fork lemmy and change it to inflict ads on your instance users you could do that, too.
I’m not thinking it’s an awesome business proposition right now, but if the fediverse gets big enough that users are willing to pay for Enterprise Reliability™ then I could see it happening.
It used to be that you could self-host your email server or use your cool friend’s server. But these days almost everybody uses commercial hosting. I see lemmy and mastodon going the same way if they grow enough.
People would probably pay for exclusivity, however one chooses to define that.
For ONLY $50/month YOU can join the elite! Act now!
Fuck yeah it is.
That’s the beauty of it! Just like email, it doesn’t really matter which provider you sign up through. It gives you choice.
However, some instances do de-federate from other ones meaning you wouldn’t be able to see any content from communities hosted on them nor anything posted by their users.
Awesome username.
My instance doesn’t seem to allow me to see downvotes. Makes the place seem nicer, but leaves me only ratioing to determine if something was disliked
This is more of a support question, related to using Lemmy. Please see the sidebar for a list of communities that offer support. Removing under rule #3.