cross-posted from: https://discuss.tchncs.de/post/2444019
I have electronics and digital design/verification background (MSc and some industry experience). As in the title, I am interested in learning and lately I got particularly interested in formal verification and started reading books, watching tutorials, on top of applying it at work. I really would like to learn more, participate to its advancement and contribute even slightest. I also enjoy academic environment. This is why I am considering a PhD. However leaving my job for full-time PhD means significant paycut even if I get into a funded PhD, also I am here on visa and many programs require you to pay the difference between foreign student price and domestic student price out of your packet, after receiving the funding. So leaving my job is likely not an option. I thought about doing a PhD part-time on top of my job. It will be very time and energy consuming, but I think I can take that. My bigger concern is, part-time PhD will take long time (6-8 years) and field is ever-changing, I am afraid my thesis may become irrelevant by the time I finish it. Also what I hear is that, if you do it part-time, you will not get the best subjects since professors would like to provide better supervision to and quick return from a full-time student. So I am hesitant about a PhD, even though it was something I was thinking of since a very young age. What do you think about a PhD, do you have any advice, some opportunity or downside which I did not consider? And if not with a PhD, how do I learn and research more? Reading and taking online courses are always options, but the problem is without any supervision, clear goal and guidance, I am sure I will get sidetracked and it may not be very fruitful.
A loosely moderated place to ask open-ended questions
Search asklemmy 🔍
If your post meets the following criteria, it’s welcome here!
- Open-ended question
- Not offensive: at this point, we do not have the bandwidth to moderate overtly political discussions. Assume best intent and be excellent to each other.
- Not regarding using or support for Lemmy: context, see the list of support communities and tools for finding communities below
- Not ad nauseam inducing: please make sure it is a question that would be new to most members
- An actual topic of discussion
Looking for support?
Looking for a community?
- Lemmyverse: community search
- sub.rehab: maps old subreddits to fediverse options, marks official as such
- !lemmy411@lemmy.ca: a community for finding communities
Icon by @Double_A@discuss.tchncs.de
- 0 users online
- 270 users / day
- 977 users / week
- 2.46K users / month
- 5.61K users / 6 months
- 1 subscriber
- 3.07K Posts
- 119K Comments
- Modlog
Hi I have one. Grad school was the most fun part of my life, but let me give you some advice:
Your relationship with your advisor makes or breaks grad school for you. Don’t take a gamble.
Research is not what most people think it’s going to be. Almost regardless of field these days, get ready to learn how to write code, and get ready to teach yourself everything.
If they don’t have a plan to pay your salary for at least 4 years, don’t bother. No, you can’t count on external money in this funding climate.
Read the book “getting what you came for”
Talk to potential advisors. The ones you want to be with won’t have time to talk to you. It’s a paradox.
You want to be a person who wants a “hands-off” advisor, and then you want to get one. If you want a hands-on advisor, my advice is to go do some work on your confidence, and come back when you think you’re ready to teach yourself everything.
Don’t go into grad school thinking you know what you will work on. Projects evolve and change based on funding and whims and chance.
Adding to this:
Also don’t worry about your research being irrelevant. Most phd projects are niche and cutting edge. You will be pushing your field forward, you’re not just along for the ride anymore as a phd.
That’s all fantastic advice, thanks for adding to my post! Especially agree about not worrying about broad impact in grad school.
The experience will be exactly what you make of it. Yes you might have trouble of finding your initial advisor taking you on a part-time role. But if you can demonstrate domain knowledge, the ability to be more functional, less handholding than a normal student, you can build a relationship with an advisor and be able to woo them into your increased contributions even at a part-time level.
If you love learning, and doing research, and being challenged, and forced to self-evaluate, do it. It’s a great experience. It is a long experience. But it’s great
It is definitely not something I will rush. There is nothing that forces me to get PhD right away so I will wait until I find something very interesting, and a good advisor.
Hey! I’m in a similar boat. I also do electronics design and can’t deal with the 100% pay cut that a PhD would incur. At least not yet.
My current solution is just to research things on my own, without a university. I design things I think might be interesting, then get the boards made at a factory (cheap these days), then populate them and test it out. Cost tends to be quite low per project (under 100$ even for fairly advanced things like particle physics). Then I write it up online or do a conference talk if people think it’s interesting enough – and if they don’t, I really don’t care: I’m already all about the next project!
If I strip away all the “publish or perish” nonsense as well as grant applications and teaching requirements, it turns out I can do a satisfying amount of research in my spare time. Equipment costs are not a disaster either – maybe a 1000$ oscilloscope (which I need for work anyway), but very ordinary other stuff otherwise.
A good side effect is the stuff I work on keeps me sharp at work, and on rare occasions produces something commercially useful. It also forms a body of work that I use to advance my career, as examples of neat stuff I know how to do. I’d have a hard time putting a number do it, but I’d estimate my research has a negative cost.
Right now, I’m trying to do audio processing in 16 bytes of RAM and under 500 bytes of program. So far, it looks like it will work, but I don’t know yet!
I’m not sure of your country, but are you tied to it? (For example, do you have family, or are trying to attain citizenship?)
Opening up your search might be helpful. Look at a variety of universities in many countries to see what options there are.
Can you switch to a job with more of a research focus? Maybe that is hard to find in the area that you want (I have no idea what formal verification actually is).
As someone who has been through it the mental and financial toll is indeed significant, so you are smart to be asking about it.
Thank you for your advice. It is a nice idea to look for a job with more research focus. I am guessing the tool vendors may offer research related jobs regarding formal verification which limits the options to a few US-based companies, but I will definitely look into it.